I was having dinner at a yakitori place with my brother a few days ago, and in the far corner, saw that the TV was on. They were showing a story about something new that the Tokyo traffic cops have: onboard radar.
In Tokyo (and probably it’s the same elsewhere in Japan), traffic cops are very specific, highly annoying, and completely ineffectual at what they are supposed to be doing. Ostensibly, they are supposed to be monitoring traffic for safety. In reality, it’s all a show.
First off, traffic cops are almost exclusively on motorcycles. I have rarely seen a police car pull over a vehicle, and it may not even have been for a traffic violation. Instead, the motorcycle cops, on large white bikes (“shirobai”) and wearing powder blue uniforms, take care of traffic tickets.
Second, they are picky about when they serve. They are never–repeat, never–out at night or in precipitation.
Third, they choose their prey with severe prejudice. Motorcycles and scooters are at extreme risk, far beyond the proportions of illegal driving habits. Cars are next in line. If you drive a taxi or a truck, you’re golden–they are rarely, if ever, ticketed, despite commonly illegal and dangerous driving habits.
And fourth, they don’t ticket you for being unsafe anyway. They ticket you, apparently, simply because they can, and they have a seasonal quota to fill. Let me explain more on this last point. Police don’t stop people for being dangerous, just for breaking petty rules. Like making a right turn at a three-lane intersection on a 50cc scooter. If it’s 51cc scooter, or a 2-lane intersection, you’re fine. Making the illegal version of the turn is in no way, shape, or form dangerous. And the practice of not patrolling at night or in the rain–times when driving is at its most dangerous and the most lives would be saved by enforcing the rules–flies in the face of the “safety” mission. The traffic cops must have a great union.
Furthermore, police here don’t monitor traffic at danger points. I know a very dangerous street full of blind corners, where there are no sidewalks, pedestrians crossing all over the place, and cars speeding. To top it off, a big police station is at the end of the street. And the cops never monitor traffic there.
Where do they monitor it? Where it’s easy to catch people. At the biggest intersections–not because accidents happen there, but because it is the easiest place to break a law, and since you’re going slowly, they can stop you more easily. (Yes, a few will speed past, I’ve seen it–and the cops didn’t do anything.) At overpasses and underpasses–again, not for safety, these are usually safe as houses–but because they can hide very easily, and pull you over just as easily.
And speeding, until now, was restricted to long, straight, empty, countryside roads with no intersections, crosswalks, or cross traffic of any kind, where the speed limit is ridiculously low (usually half the actual safe speed), and where you can’t turn off on side roads to evade capture. Shooting fish in a barrel. One guy clocks you, and then down the road, another guy flags you down and sits you at a desk where one of a line of policemen give you your ticket in assembly-line form (usually for driving 40 mph in a 25 mph zone that would be 50 mph if it were in the U.S.).
But now, it appears, the motorcycle cops have onboard radar, so they can officially clock your speed either while parked or while driving. A machine on their dash calculates the speed and spits out a sticker.
So are the streets of Tokyo safer? No, of course not. The traffic cops still stick to the areas of easy pickings. But there will be one small change: slightly more unpredictability. You see, one more point about traffic cops being for show and not for real is predictability. They always patrol the same intersections; the speed traps are always in the same places; they always are out in the daytime in good weather. If you know where they are and when they are there, you can violate traffic laws with impunity, slowing down only when you get to a hot spot. And you can tell this by the way some people drive in Japan.
So the new onboard radar thing will have an effect… but only where they use it, which I will bet you is only on the stretches of the main roads near big intersections, as always. That’s where they were doing their thing on the TV show I glimpsed at the yakitori place.
This is one of the reasons why the police don’t get much respect in Japan. The low crime rate is not due to their effectiveness, that’s for certain.
This is not helped by the licensing system. When I got my motorcycle license renewed, we all had to take a driving test. The test was extremely non-real-world in nature, and penalized you for very piddling stuff–like resting on one foot instead of the other when you stop (your foot near the gear shift has to not be bearing your weight; I suppose shifting weight while stopped is illegal). I saw guys taking the test who seemed fine to me, and they were failed. Beats me as to why–piddling stuff, it must have been. When I took my test, I did fine–but they docked me points anyway, and declared I would have to go to driving school for x number of hours. When I went, the lessons had zero relationship to the things they faulted me for on the test. They made me drive a simulator which felt completely different from a real bike, and which I drove safely despite them throwing unreal stuff at me, until apparently I hit the end of the run and they had some virtual driver blindside me.
So why was I sent to school? Because pretty much everyone is; the guys who did perfectly well but were flunked had to go back to driving school for a lot more hours than I did. They had to pay very high fees to do so. And that’s where the flavor of corruption comes in: the schools and the driving center have connections. I was directed to go to a specific school. Just like the motorcycle cops get a cut of the traffic tickets they hand out during “safety drives,” money infects the system.
And the punitive stuff if you get tickets is useless as far as safety goes. If you get tickets, then when your license renewal comes up, you have to attend traffic school for most of the day. The school is a video-and-lecture, and doesn’t address the violations the captive audience is there for. If you get enough tickets to rake up 6 points off of your license within a certain time period, then you get suspended for 30 days unless you attend an all-day lecture, and must take a test as well. The questions again are pretty much unrelated to your violation.
In short, it’s all just for show, and has little or nothing to do with safety. As for the tickets and fines, unless you are a safe driver to the point of neurosis, you are bound to get them. I myself see them as a driving tax; you just get them and there’s not much you can do about it.