A Little Late to the Game, Dude
From an article titled “White Fright” from Slate:
In a rather curious and confused way, some white people are starting almost to think like a minority, even like a persecuted one.
“Starting”? What, this guy’s catching on to the phenomenon only now? Sheesh. I’ve been blogging about it for years. Back in 2003, the year I started blogging, I noted the cause as being:
When we gain something, we tend to believe it is earned, not stolen; when we lose something, we do feel that a deserved reward has been taken from us. Similarly, white men are used to a superior position, and believe it is their due; when the scales are made more balanced, it feels to them as if something they have earned is being unfairly stolen and given to someone who does not deserve it.
Whites in general, up until the 60’s at least, were far disproportionately advantaged; they had more wealth, more power, more influence, more everything relative to a balanced norm. And while no one acknowledged it, it was clear that the advantage was taken, not earned.
Minorities were not underachievers; they were, like the term or not, oppressed. Most family lines started from literally nothing in this country, and were denied most opportunities open to whites; they received substandard education, and were constantly discriminated against and shut out, a situation that lasted openly for a century after slavery was ended, and has continued more quietly since.
But to a white person, who had indeed worked hard all of his life, the idea that any of his position or status was due to others being actively kept down was considered insulting. Racism was rationalized and/or committed out of sight, distanced from the positive achievements of white individuals. Few whites would ever know they got a position because a minority was turned down out of their field of view, by an individual who did so because of race but would never admit to it.
No, whites felt they had what they had because it was rightfully theirs. Their race, their religion, their views, all naturally dominant. So when it started being less than dominant, there was no other explanation than that it was being stolen from them. Because if it weren’t, that meant their position in life wasn’t 100% honestly earned, and that was not something they would consider.
It helped that while the unfair elements that helped them were so easily dismissed, and yet even the weak and partial systems of redress, such affirmative action regulations and legislative & court-ordered quotas, were not only visible but so easily vilified. Over the past 40 years, little if any racism in matters of record is overtly committed, and so is deniable as a cause (we are, after all, a “color blind” society now, and any accusation of racism is vehemently and automatically denied as an unfair charge no matter how outrageous the offense), and so whites can act as it there was nothing helping them at all.
Minorities are told that any achievement they make must be viewed as tainted if there is a chance that any equalling program played even a small role in their achievements, but few if any whites ever insist that they must feel the same way themselves about racial discrimination or past advantages ever being a factor in their achievements. So we have the mindset that there is little or no racism by whites, but that there is a good deal of “reverse racism” that subjugates them.
Whites have started to see their supremacy slip, and can only conclude that it is being stolen, and so they are oppressed. Christianity is naturally dominant (didn’t you know that everything we are as a country owes its origins to Christianity?) and so Christianity not being allowed into every last crevice is persecution.
It’s hard being a white Christian male. We suffer so.

The myth of the Persecuted Majority is perhaps the oldest conservative false issue ever. It might also be the most dangerous, and most irresponsible.
This goes back to Hitler who loved the Persecuted Majority myth: Germany didn’t lose World War I, they didn’t deserve to be rendered unemployed by the Great Depression, no, they suffered from being stabbed in the back by Jews, Liberals, Social Democracts and Commununist.
Here’s the problem with that; when the persecuted majority finally got power, they felt justified and unaccountable for in ‘stabbing back’ and so they did to horrific effect.
Nixon did his own much more benign “silent majority” riff on this sort of thing.
I don’t think most white males are conscious of the advantages they enjoy: they apply for a job, they get the job – they think they did what they were suppose to do: go out and find the best job they could. The guy doing the hiring is guilty of discrimination. Therefore I don’t think most Americans think they are guilty of anything and are angry for having to be defensive about doing what they were supposed to do: go out an get a job and hold it. When they suddenly find that they can’t do that, then they become vulnerable to Republican politics of the persecuted majority.
Of course the Persecuted Majority is an absurdity, especially in a democracy. That, I think, demonstrates the overall character of all Republican/conservative politics.
Most family lines started from literally nothing in this country, and were denied most opportunities open to whites; they received substandard education, and were constantly discriminated against and shut out, a situation that lasted openly for a century after slavery was ended, and has continued more quietly since.
This is important actually. In the period of 1865-1900 or so, there was still good land free for the taking thanks to the Homestead Act, up to 160 acres.
This was a great social relief valve and equalizer, and when I read an article drawing a connection between the rise of the social progressive movements that emerged from the Populist movements, and how land pressures began to move the country towards less “rugged individualism” and more towards the forms of social progressivism and outright 社会主義 that Europe was beginning to develop (due to its own severe population pressures), it made sense to me.
But back to the point of minorities they were largely shut out of this original distribution, and in game terms that’s like having people join a Monopoly game halfway into it — they’re going to be continually behind the power curve and screwed.
Of course, there’s a lot more “noise” in real life, but the wealth of one’s grandparents will correlate pretty well to your own relative success in life.