Net Neutrality: Down But Not Out
You may have heard that a few days ago, a provision for Network Neutrality was voted down in the House 269-152. While a few Republicans voted for neutrality and several dozen Democrats voted against it, the vote was mostly along party lines, with Republicans against and Democrats for. Lobbyists won the day, bribing away like madmen; in an expensive election year, bribery is all too welcome in Congress.
While this loss is discouraging, it is not the end of the battle. It only means that the House will not positively vote for Net Neutrality; it does not yet mean that the House and the Senate will decisively vote against it when (and if) the telecom bill gets through Congress.
One more point to add to prior observations: the telecoms are trying to say that the big Internet media companies want to use these fast lanes for free to deliver content to you online. Aside from the untruth I noted before that these companies already pay high fees to the telecoms and get nothing for free, there is another fallacy: the metaphor of the goods being “delivered” to you, as if it’s the Microsofts and Googles which are the ones traversing the information superhighway. The fact is, no one is “on” these highways or “in” these pipes. However, if anyone is using these pathways, it is you. The content providers simply make things available at their end. You are the one who chooses to initiate the contact and receive the content. Much more than the content companies, you are the one who is doing the traversing. Which means that you’re the same greedy bastard that the telecoms are attacking for using their “pipes” for “free.” Are you? Do you get a free Internet connection? Or are the telecoms lying?
What it comes down to is whether you get to choose what comes across the Internet to you at high speed. If the telecoms get their way, you get no choice–they get to choose, and they get to charge money for it, money which you eventually have to pay, whether it is directly to them, or to them through the content providers. If Net Neutrality wins, then you get to decide what goes fast on the Internet, simply by requesting it. And it won’t cost a penny more in the end.
The fight’s not over. It’s not too late. Do something.






