Insane
Republicans were already way over the top when they became mock-outraged at the Democrats blocking 10 Bush judicial nominees, less than 5% of the total number passed. Republicans blocked 60 or more of Clinton’s nominees, some by filibuster, and most by a procedural method with the same effect of a filibuster–a procedural method they banned after Bush took office so as to deny it to Democrats.
Republicans have so far acted on this issue with nothing but extreme hypocrisy and dishonesty, and here’s the rundown. First they protested Democrats not letting a judicial nominee get a vote on the Senate floor; but then it was recognized that Republicans usually blocked Clinton’s nominees with the “blue slip” rule which prevented an up-or-down vote on the Senate floor. Hypocrisy.
Then Republicans railed against Democrats for using the filibuster, even citing times when it was used to block civil-rights legislation, with Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist condemning the tactic of filibustering a judicial nominee, calling it “unprecedented.” But then it came out that not only had Republicans filibustered Democratic judicial nominees before, but that Frist himself had joined in one in 1994. Not to mention that the filibusters used against civil-rights legislation were, naturally, Republican filibusters. Hypocrisy upon hypocrisy.
Then they decided to do away with the filibuster, which they themselves had used and counted on in the past; this action is what Republicans themselves termed as the “nuclear option.” That term was coined by Republican Senator Trent Lott, and was used freely by Republicans–until their polling data showed that the term was viewed negatively by the public, upon which revelation Republicans not only switched to the term “constitutional option,” but went into a successful full-court media press to claim that Democrats had come up with the expression (which most of the press still reports, even though it has been thoroughly disproved). Even more hypocrisy.
So now they’re pushing the term “constitutional option,” which is, of course, inaccurate:
Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist of Tennessee calls the possibility of enabling a simple majority to end a filibuster the “constitutional option,” implying that the Constitution is on his side. The Constitution says two things relevant to his argument.Article II, Sec. 2 gives presidents the power to “nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the Supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States.” It doesn’t say how the Senate shall grant this consent, and it makes no distinction between judicial and nonjudicial appointments.
Republicans read this language as requiring the Senate to provide an up-or-down floor vote on all judicial nominees.
Article I, Sec. 5, says that “each House may determine the Rules of its Proceedings.” Senate rules require 60 votes to end a filibuster and — even worse for the Republicans — require 67 votes to end a filibuster of a proposed change in the rules.
In short, the constitution not only doesn’t prohibit the filibuster, it actually upholds the process. Not hypocrisy by the Republicans on this point, but certainly an out-and-out lie.
But now they’re going even further over the top, this time in attempts to smear Democrats in order to gain public approval. According to Republicans, Democrats are racist Nazis. And no, I’m not making that up.
Republican Senator Rick Santorum is now claiming that Democrats are acting like Nazis, comparing them directly to Adolf Hitler.
Republican Bill Frist is now hauling out the old canard that because one of the blocked nominees is black, that means that Democrats are obviously all racists (and probably sexists as well) because they fear putting a black woman on the bench.
All of this because Democrats had the gall to block a third as many Bush judicial nominees as Republicans had with Clinton, a sliver-thin 5% of all the extremist judges Bush sent their way. Rage, hypocrisy, lies, and ludicrous accusations of fascism and racism.
These people are certifiably insane.


















